Judge who halts Sal DiMasi hearing a former donor

Photo by Herald file

The judge who abruptly pulled the plug yesterday on a hearing over indicted former House Speaker Salvatore DiMasi’s bid to have his state pension restored gave $50 to the disgraced pol’s election campaign in August 1990, the Herald has learned.

DiMasi’s attorney, Thomas R. Kiley, was a character witness for Boston Municipal Court Judge Raymond G. Dougan Jr. when, three months later, in November 1990, Dougan was nominated an associate justice by then-Gov. Michael S. Dukakis, according to state records.

Dougan, 65, still has DiMasi’s case before him but has postponed it until June 30 so he can confer with BMC Chief Justice Charles Johnson “to determine who is best suited to hear the matter,” said Joan Kenney, state court spokeswoman.

DiMasi, 64, was an assistant Suffolk district attorney in the mid-1970s and later a private attorney who possibly stood before any number of jurists.

The endangered Democrat’s $4,952-per-month retirement allowance has been held up since November while he awaits trial in federal court on mail fraud and conspiracy charges alleging he took $57,000 in bribes from a software company in exchange for state contracts.

DiMasi has pleaded not guilty and claims he needs his pension to pay for his defense and to live.

“I need my retirement allowance to support myself and my family,” he said in court documents. “I had a thriving legal practice until I became speaker but restricted it upon becoming speaker (in 2004) to avoid conflicts and the appearance of conflicts.”

DiMasi resigned his State House seat on Jan. 27, 2009, prior to being indicted. Kiley could not be reached for comment last night.

Article URL: http://www.bostonherald.com/news/politics/view.bg?articleid=1261647

CLICK HERE – Article Courtesy of MASS LIVE

Love Triangle Assault – Susan Dawson

Agawam mayor Susan Dawson attacked at Max’s Tavern in Springfield

Posted by mbrault April 08, 2009 22:19PM

Susan R. Dawson

By PATRICK JOHNSON
pjohnson@repub.com

SPRINGFIELD – Agawam Mayor Susan R. Dawson was attacked by another woman Wednesday night as she left the ladies’ room at Max’s Tavern by the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame, police said.

Police were called to the restaurant at about 9 p.m for a report of an injured woman. Dawson told police she was thrown to the ground and struck her head. She also told police that while she was on the ground she was kicked more than once.

Police said there were no visible signs of injury, and Dawson was taken by ambulance to Baystate Medical Center.

A 61-year-old Longmeadow woman was identified as the assailant. Police have not charged the woman, whose identity was not disclosed. Dawson can file an assault and battery complaint in District Court.

Police said Wednesday night it was unclear what prompted the attack. The two women know one another, police said.

The Longmeadow woman fled the scene before police arrived.

Categories: Agawam, Crime, Springfield

From the Howie Carr Show:

When Scorned Women Attack!!!

• Pair Tumbles out of lady’s room screaming expletives.
  
• Cougar Cat Fight Puts Agawam Animal Control Over Budget
• Susan says : “I will not Confirm or Deny what the public is saying.”
  


Howie Carr

A fight –apparently over a man, spilled over into a popular Massachusetts Springfield eatery on the Riverfront last night. Springfield Police have not commented, but the mayor of Agawam Susan Dawson became involved with a fight with a 61 year old woman from nearby Longmeadow. Onlookers tell us the fight was over a man. Is this the state of local politics today?

Mayor Dawson before and after extreme makeover…

CLICK HERE – Article Courtesy of MASS LIVE

Agawam Mayor Susan Dawson seeks complaint against Longmeadow woman she says attacked her at Max’s Tavern in Springfield

Posted by dbshepar April 09, 2009 15:31PM

File photo by Bob Stern / The RepublicanAgawam Mayor Susan R. Dawson is seen giving a speech following her swearing-in ceremony last year.

By BUFFY SPENCER
bspencer@repub.com

SPRINGFIELD – Agawam Mayor Susan R. Dawson filed an application for a complaint Thursday afternoon against a 61-year-old Longmeadow woman who allegedly attacked her as she left the ladies’ room at Max’s Tavern in Springfield Wednesday night.

Dawson and West Springfield lawyer Charles Sclafani went to the Springfield District Court Clerk’s office at about 2:30 p.m. and filed a request for a criminal complaint against Celeste Benoit, the two said as they left the building.

The filing of requests for complaints by individuals is not public information, nor is the complaint.

It could not be immediately determined if Benoit, of Blokland Drive, had filed a request for a complaint, too.

Sclafani said Dawson is requesting that Benoit be charged with assault and battery and assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, a shoe.

Police were called to the restaurant in the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame building at about 9 p.m. Wednesday for a report of an injured woman. Dawson told police she was thrown to the ground and struck her head. She also told police that while she was on the ground she was kicked more than once.

Police said there were no visible signs of injury, and Dawson was taken by ambulance to Baystate Medical Center in Springfield.

Police said Wednesday night it was unclear what prompted the attack. The two women know one another, police said.

Police said Benoit fled the scene before police arrived.

More details in The Republican tomorrow.

Categories: Agawam, Crime, Longmeadow, Springfield

Comments

QueenMaryJ says…

You GO Girl!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 4:46PM

travelbuddy says…

On 22 news Dawson just said there was “maybe 1 reason” she could think of that would provoke such a confrontation. Wonder if that reason is Dawson has been living with that woman’s husband for the past year?

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:18PM

rukidding75 says…

Of course she’s going to face it head on. She’s a strong woman!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:18PM

travelbuddy says…

On 22 news Dawson just said there was “maybe 1 reason” she could think this woman would target her. Maybe that reason is because Dawson has been living with this womans husband for the past year. Convenient she forgot that details during the interview.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:19PM

dgotbooted says…

This is such a funny story. fortunately no one was injured, but if a 61 yr old lady whooped me, i’d go home with my tail between my legs and keep quiet!!!! lmao

I hope when i am 61 i will still be i a$$ whooping shape, you go granny

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:34PM

waltersd says…

Still cant believe this women won the race for mayor.. Very funny story yes indeed. Women like her always seem to come out smelling like roses.

Susan by the way you really haven’t done anything for special needs kids in this town… So stop saying you have…

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:49PM

joesa92 says…

If the mayor is living with this womans husband,so what!They are probably getting divorced anyway.She should have dropped the soon to be ex,but once again another scorned b***h!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:52PM

liza01 says…

Why would the mayor stoop to accepting someone elses baggage.She is fairly attractive for her age.There are plenty of men her age that dont carry with them a 61 year old ex that can obviously kick some butt.I wouldnt feel too sorry for the granny,she lives in Longmeadow,how bad is that?Im sure shes getting the house car and everything else of his.BOO_HOO_HOO!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:58PM

rukidding75 says…

I love how everyone focuses on the fact that the “61 year old woman won the fight”, however, how much abuse would you be giving Mayor Dawson if she was in a bar brawl as an active participant? Give me a break, people. She has endured more than most and still comes out on top. People always want to trample the strong women, but here she is – facing it and she’s going to get through it as she always has.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 6:00PM

swinger469 says…

I can tell you this if a 61 year old hag attacks you,you “DON’T” fight back !!! You can’t win. This would have looked much worse if she ponded the slot out of grandma !!! Grandma is CRAZY !!!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 6:05PM

northside9 says…

I wish these people from Agawam and Longmeadow would stop bringing their violence to Springfield.

And what’s with the people from other towns burning their cars and themselves in Springfield. Do it in your own town!

There’s not a crime problem in Springfield, there’s a crime problem in the suburbs that keeps coming into Springfield!!!!!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 6:49PM Footer

Comments

brende58 says…

Sounds like 2 white rich women fighting over a worthless man. Heard Jerry Springer show was coming to CT guess they’ll be his 1st guest.

Posted on 04/08/09 at 10:45PM

homesick27 says…

that was my 1st thought. over a man. who cheated on who? They were probably drunk.

Posted on 04/08/09 at 11:11PM

tranquil says…

61 year old woman can kick a$$. Gives women everywhere hope.

No visible injuries? Maybe it didn’t really happen.

Posted on 04/08/09 at 11:14PM

QueenMaryJ says…

Mrs. Six?

Posted on 04/08/09 at 11:17PM

NoPol says…

Why isn’t the residence of the attacker in the headline? Following past practices at Masslive, the headline should read “Agawam mayor Susan Dawson attacked by Longmeadow Woman at Max’s Tavern in Springfield”.

Masslive seems eager to point it out when a Springfield resident commits a crime in another community.

Posted on 04/08/09 at 11:24PM

hellfish says…

Stay classy Agawam

Posted on 04/08/09 at 11:38PM

cozy77 says…

Poor thing,thrown to the ground,hit in the head and just for good measure she was kicked more than once.I’m not a Dr.but I do know that white people who have things like this happen to them their skin is red.Sounds like maybe a little “white” lie.

Posted on 04/08/09 at 11:42PM

letsgossip says…

I’ve seen the Honorable Mayor in action, I’m not impressed perhaps her head is getting to big to fit through the door…. it’s call EGO! Madamme Mayor, stop the MMA (mixed martial arts) fighting skits and start fighting for the people that elected you! Only an observation.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:03AM

noncrazy says…

Mayor said she was attacked when she left the ladies room,hum? A 61 yr old Longmeadow woman is the suspect.No marks on the Mayor well seems to me that is an elbow problem.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:32AM

SPFLDDAD says…

Agree with NoPol. Guaranteed if a Spfld resident attacked the Agawam Mayor the headlines would read
“Springfield resident attacks mayor” or if a Spfld resident did this in a surrounding community the Spfld part would be pointed out. We have enough troubles here without the republican adding more fuel to the fire.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:39AM

parkperson says…

It was over a man she fell to the ground pleading for her to stop it was not even a good cat fight.. she think’s she can crap on everyone now thats she’s Mayor..woo hoo.. stop trying to pick up other womens rich men there Miss Dawson.. and have another bottle of wine..

Posted on 04/09/09 at 1:59AM

snookered1 says…

Hmm… I wonder if alcohol was involved?

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:07AM

Nichobi says…

Yes, I think they were trying to impersonate MMArtists! But, seeing how there were no visible signs of any altercation I would lean towards “to drunk to stay verticle” CRASH!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 6:03AM

derek1824 says…

Taking bets on whether or not the mayor privately sues the woman for this altercation.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 6:36AM

iknowall19 says…

Seeing this ladies husband.. also going with a married man from chicopee.. She is a real class act.. No lie..

Posted on 04/09/09 at 7:39AM

nicholz12 says…

….if a Spfld resident attacked the Agawam Mayor the headlines would read
“Springfield resident attacks mayor”

if the shoe fits wear it….

Posted on 04/09/09 at 7:41AM

IrishGirl79 says…

Does anybody know who the Longmeadow woman was? I grew up there. It could be somebody’s mom that I went to school with. That would be hilarious!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 7:56AM

skyjack2 says…

mussure there not from chicopee

Posted on 04/09/09 at 7:58AM

asprin says…

all re the headline issue rite on, before i got to the story i assumed that it was a parking lot assault and would include a name or description of a hispanic perp, happy to see neither. now, if the 61 yo perp squeeze from longmortgage turns out to be hispanic, well, i’ll just have to start over…

Posted on 04/09/09 at 8:19AM

tjmnrccske says…

I am caucasion and do not live in springfield but i can certainly see the injustice in reporting practices. if the attacker was an hispanic or african-american i believe they would have released and printed her name. she enjoys anonimity because of her social status and ethnicity. shame on the republican. just my opinion!!!!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 8:23AM

cmb1957 says…

You can bet that if the attacker was a woman from Springfield her name and address would have prominently displayed in the article. What a joke this paper is with their double standards

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:01AM

russ888 says…

Eh, she probably just took cuts in the “ladies” room or didn’t hand tissue to the stall with an empty roll. MEOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:10AM

TeaParty says…

cmb1957, Maybe Dawson did not give the name of her attacker to the police. Since the Longmeadow woman was not arrested, it would not be wise for the Republican or the police to release the womans name. I will agree the Republican is pretty cautious how they report stories about crime in other towns. No town want’s a bad reputation so the police will not release much information about the crime. No information, no story.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:22AM

vupt says…

The Republican needs to come clean on the Longmeadow woman’s identity. Inquiring minds want to know!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:27AM

rukidding75 says…

I’m sorry, but hasn’t she been a huge improvement over the last Mayor? Has she made promises and kept them? You guys sit here and criticize and make assumptions and judgments about her personal life, but how many of you love Bill Clinton and what he did with his administration?

I love the double standards between women and men. Sure, Bill was publicly criticized, but most would agree he did a lot for his country. Similarly, Mayor Dawson is doing a lot for Agawam.

I also want to agree that if the attacker was African American or Hispanic, that fact would have definitely been mentioned. Are we supposed to assume that the attacker is white because of the lack of mention – apparently so. So, in that case, “white” is understood. Wrong – so wrong! We need to call out white people who break the law, and if we are going to report items of interest such as this, all races, since we are clearly still defining people according to race and ethnicity should be mentioned…or not at all.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:32AM

BUCKYKATT says…

This mayor goes out drinking EVERY night and sometimes during the day. She is an elected official and should be working like everyone else.
I have witnessed her pompous behavior while having dinner and was appalled that she appeared to have no problem who saw her downing that extra bottle of wine. Nice job picking that gem of a lady Agawam!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:37AM

QueenMaryJ says…

Admit it, you just want to see her standing in front of “the wall”.

I know I do.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:37AM

roxy1954 says…

Maybe she should stay away from someone else husband and get a Man of her owen

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:40AM

rukidding75 says…

Does it take forever for a comment to post – or is masslive only posting comments that are negative about the Mayor? I’m new to this…

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:41AM

ahsmom says…

Everyone who lives in Agawam knmows who this women who attacked Ms. Dawson is. She is the wife of Ms. Dawson’s live in boyfriend. Dawson will NOT press charges its too messy as it is.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:48AM

Lgriffin says…

Mrs. Longmeadow,

“That’s so ghetto.”

Posted on 04/09/09 at 9:50AM

agresser says…

Everyone in this thread, including the two brawling chicks are idiots.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:06AM

CitySlicker2 says…

I agree the double standards used in reporting on Masslive, Republican and all local news stations are injust. Sensationalism is what they subscribe to and in the interim they tip the scales against Springfield. Very irresponsible! Oh, and it had happened accross the river it would have been “in the Greater Springfield area”.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:16AM

sfieldres says…

I think it’s pretty sad that the majority of the posters on here are so small and are extremely quick to judge. No one knows what all of the circumstances are- of the incident or of the relationships these people have with one another, or all of the facts. It’s no one’s business but their own.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:18AM

mustluvkats says…

What’s wrong aggresser you’re not getting the attention at home that you craved? Mommy smoking meth again? So now you want feedback from us? well, not from me your not worth my time FOOL!!!!!!! You probably one of those idiots that keep checking the thread for a response to your idiotic comment. GO GET YOUR ATTENTION FIX SOMEWHERE ELSE.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:33AM

WhyGoHome says…

That’ll depend on an arrest being made. That’s journalism 101.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:39AM

fazoot says…

Does Max’s Tavern have an entertainment license for the Cat Fights?

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:45AM

tjmnrccske says…

if they wanted privacy perhaps they should not have been brawling in a public place. if they kept their argument between the two of them and fought in a private venue, this story would never have been printed. since it was printed the reader deserves to know the names of the parties involved. the article states that a 61 year old longmeadow woman was identified, so obviously the reporter knows her identity.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:50AM

shelsby says…

Well perhaps if she didnt FREQUENT the bar and embarress herself on a regular basis, she wouldnt incite patrons whether they know her or not!!!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:56AM

spfldsux says…

Despite this issue being about an “Agawam Mayor” and a resident of “Longmeadow”; a meteor still should hit Springfield and wipe it out.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 10:56AM

rukidding75 says…

Nice, spfldsux. Hate much?

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:11AM

spfldsux says…

I hate the gangs, violence, crime. I hate what Springfield has become. A cesspool.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:15AM

thecynic77 says…

Something is wrong here!!! If a regualr everyday citizen assulted someone, the police will arrest the person, regardsless if the victim presses charges or not. Looks like Sprinfield PD have a double standard. Rich and politcal/famous people get a second chance, while regular citizens get arrested in the same situation. Its good to know that police corruption is still alive and well in MA, it would be a shame for the police to actually follow the rules/laws for everybody equally.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:16AM

spfldsux says…

Exactly. Springfield = corruption; therefore, gangs, crime, violence. nuf said.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:18AM

sfieldres says…

Mayor Dawson was the one that was attacked- not the other way around- the other woman is the one who should have been arrested! You would know if you had been there!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:24AM

rukidding75 says…

Not all the people who live in Springfield participate in criminal activity. There are many of us law-abiding citizens who live here and want to make a difference. Do you want to wipe us out too – or do you have a suggestion on how we can improve the economy and therefore the financial means to move out of the city before it is wiped out?

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:27AM

hellfish says…

Mayor McDrunk needs to step down

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:33AM

thecynic77 says…

I realize the Mayor is the Victim, regardless of who the victim is, nobody was arrested. The 61 year old longmeadow woman is and the mayor know eachother, thats why her name isn’t in the paper and thats why whe hasn’t been arrested. Thats favoritism, and its wrong. A law has been broken, regardless of who broke it proper action should have been taken.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:49AM

foodjunky101 says…

I used to see Dawson at Maxs every thursday – each and everytime getting polluted out of her mind. The week before she was elected mayor she was in Maxs making out with a guy in the middle of the bar. Maybe thats how she was elected?? Well anyways she was caught on wednesday night having an affair with the 61 year old ladies husband! They dont tell you that in the paper but she was sleeping with another womans man. Thats why the altercation occurred.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:49AM

ComedyGold says…

The story goes: the 61 year old attacker is the husband of the man that the mayor is in a “relationship” with. She’s the jilted wife.

Apparently this relationship has been going on for months. Everyone knows the mayor goes to Max’s all the time. The wife probably followed them there and confronted the mayor. My guess is the guy probably just asked her for a divorce and she snapped.

This information is hearsay that I’ve heard from many different sources.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 11:53AM

moxie2 says…

If she looks like a pig; smells like a pig; and acts like a pig; she’s probably a pig.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:10PM

NoPol says…

Telling only half the story makes the city and Max’s look bad. If I was the owner of Max’s, I would be on the phone with Masslive and the Republican for their sensational headlines. The headlines make it sound like this was a random attack, that Max’s is a dangerous place.

That apparently is very far from the truth.

I don’t know why the attacker hasn’t been arrested.

A lot of the Springfield assaults written about in the Republican are committed under similar circumstances to what other posters are alleging here. I guess that when a Springfield woman assaults another woman over a man, that’s an immediate arrest, no questions asked, but if it is a Longmeadow woman doing the assault, the police give the option?

Seems not right to me.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:16PM

nissan195 says…

Let if be known, Dawson will be referred to MAYOR McDrunk until she steps down.

The lettering on her door will need to change. Guess some people think they can just do whatever they want.

Agawam started off right with Johnson, then Cohen now this POS. How can she face the residents and officials and expect them to respect her?

STEP DOWN MAYOR McDrunk!!!!!!!!!!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:42PM

whoknows1 says…

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone – Time to grow up people!If you are so brave – use your full name!!————- Thought so

Posted on 04/09/09 at 12:58PM

jeccaxoxo says…

she was attacked by the wife of the man that she was having an affair with for the past few years.

funny how that part was left out.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 1:47PM

40thieves says…

Cozy77 – Wow you really sound like an idiot. Why would you have to bring race into this? Obviously you are not a doctor….”When this happens to white people their skin turns red..” Well, Dr. Cozy77 idiot…How come we can’t tell when you black people get black eyes? You are an idiot. You must have a PHD in being a really stupid idiot

Posted on 04/09/09 at 1:52PM

hedoes says…

Maybe you should get your facts straight. The guy left his wife a year ago. The woman from Longmeadow is a bitter lady and yes she was that way when they were married…that’s why he left her. I have seen this woman first hand in action at a comedy night where she heckled the comedian to the point where he asked her to leave. None ever deserves to be beat on!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 2:02PM

ahsgrad21 says…

she was probably never attacked…she mostlikely was drunk and fell when she was walking out of the bathroom

Posted on 04/09/09 at 2:08PM

wantstruth says…

thecynic77 – This is a simple assault & Battery, no bodily injury. It was not comitted in the presence of a police officer, there is NO power of arrest for this crime.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 2:14PM

wmasscalper says…

The Mayor is perpetuating the stereotype of all Agawam whores… drinking in Springfield and doing every guy that crosses their paths I know cause I’ve had em all I think Eve and Jezebel were probably from Agawam Beware of Agawam chicks! Run away!

Posted on 04/09/09 at 4:49PM

cozy77 says…

40 thieves,I didn’t bring race into it .I made the comment that white people skin turns red when it’s hit by anything,follow me so far….therefore if there was NO TRAMUA to skin if the wasn’t ANY phsyical tramua as reported NO VISIBLE SIGNS OF INJURY.This has nothing to do with race just common sense.When writting comments about stories I wish people take the time to understand what’s being written.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 5:26PM

waltersd says…

This women has done nothing for agawam and never will, Way to go agawam you really picked a class act.

All because you didn’t want to pay for a parking permit so people can park on your lawn to head to the Big E and Six Flags. You can make money but the town cant.

Posted on 04/09/09 at 6:01PM

Woman accused of attacking Agawam mayor issues statement

AGAWAM — A woman accused of assaulting Agawam Mayor Susan Dawson in April says she witnessed her husband passionately kissing Dawson a year earlier.

Celeste Benoit released a statement through her attorney on Tuesday. A hearing is scheduled on Thursday to determine whether Benoit should face criminal charges for allegedly throwing Dawson to the ground and kicking her outside the ladies room of a Springfield restaurant.

The first-term mayor has claimed that she began dating real estate developer Mark Benoit only after he and his wife split up. But Celeste Benoit disputes that in her statement, saying the couple separated only after she confronted her husband about the romantic encounter with Dawson.

Dawson’s lawyer would not confirm or deny the March 2008 incident, but told The Republican newspaper that his client was still the victim of an “unprovoked attack.”

___

Information from: The Springfield Republican, http://www.masslive.com/news/

Article URL: http://www.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view.bg?articleid=1175073

Not a fan, felonious Tom Finneran? Well pardon me!

Photo by Nancy Lane

Are you talkin’ to me, Felon Finneran?

I quote now from the letter that four bust-out ex-governors of Massachusetts have written to President Bush, begging them to pardon former House speaker Tommy Taxes Finneran, a man so crooked he needs a corkscrew to get into his pants in the morning.

“He has suffered daily taunts and ridicule of those who believe that every elected official is the equivalent of a common thief.”

That’s me they’re talking about. When it comes to Felon Finneran, I’m in charge of daily taunts and ridicule. But despite what the Four Stooges wrote, I don’t believe every elected official is a thief. Finneran, on the other hand, was the House speaker – a job title that lately has a higher recidivism rate than godfather of the Gambino Crime Family.

As for Tommy Taxes being a “common thief” – I would never say that. Common thieves who do the crime do the time. Finneran committed multiple counts of perjury in the U.S. First Circuit Court of Appeals, but was convicted of one count of obstruction of justice, and didn’t do an hour, let alone a day, in durance vile.

And he still refuses to take responsibility for his sordid life of crime. So far, he’s Alibi Ike.

First excuse: he lied under oath because he was in a hurry to drive his wife to Mass General.

Second excuse: he’d been “gulping” Advil. No joke – Tommy Taxes claimed he was “Advil-addled.”

New excuse: I’ve ruined everything for him. Yeah, and tonight I’m going to make it snow.

The Four Stooges said Felon Finneran has been “severely punished.” Really? He’s still making big money for his wretched radio show, which we call “Sweet Sixteen,” because that’s generally about where it finishes in the ratings. The Felon usually runs neck and neck with “The River,” and sometimes he even edges the Manchester N.H. soft-rock station. Sometimes. His show is so compelling it now goes off the air at 9 instead of 10, and they’re trying to prop him up with a co-host.

Finneran should be breakin’ rocks in the hot sun. He fought the law and the law won. Although I still remember the day he was “sentenced,” and how Judge Rick Stearns was almost apologizing for having to ask him the questions every convicted felon has to answer.

Are you on drugs this morning, wiseguy? You do know you can’t own a firearm anymore, maggot. But no, it was all “Mistah Speakah” this and “I know this is a silly question but . . .” I was there in the courtroom hoping to make a victim-impact statement. See, I was at the courthouse the day Felon Finneran told his string of incredible whoppers about his racist gerrymandering scheme in the city of Boston.

I was shocked, shocked, I tell you. I tried not to let it destroy my faith in the integrity of the Massachusetts Legislature. But I can’t get over it. Then last year, the Felon speculated to Gov. Patrick that I should be taken for a one-way ride in the trunk of the governor’s Coupe Deval.

You can take the felon out of the State House, but you can’t take the State House out of the felon. President Bush, don’t enough people hate you already? You don’t need your own Marc Rich.

Article URL: http://www.bostonherald.com/news/columnists/view.bg?articleid=1144332

Tom Finneran Felon Finneran

Former House speaker Thomas M. Finneran, arriving at his Mattapan home Monday. (Globe Staff Photo / Justine Hunt)
The Boston Globe

Finneran’s gathering storm

Ex-speaker’s strongest traits may have hastened his fall

By Don Aucoin, Globe Staff | June 9, 2005

It was a spring night in 2001, and the hottest question on Beacon Hill was whether the state budget proposal about to be released by the House Ways and Means Committee would contain adequate funds for the Clean Elections Law.

The law to provide public financing of campaigns had been overwhelmingly approved by voters several years earlier, but House Speaker Thomas M. Finneran had made no secret of his hostility to it, and that had spelled doom for many a measure in the State House over the years.

That made Finneran’s response all the more surprising when a reporter asked how much money would be in the Ways and Means budget for Clean Elections. ”I literally have no idea,” Finneran said. He went on to explain that he had been so busy with other legislative matters that he had left it in the hands of Ways and Means chairman John Rogers.

The notion of a hands-off approach on something Finneran cared about so deeply ran counter to everything that was known about the controlling, detail-oriented man who ran the House. But for the eight years Finneran presided as a speaker of unchallenged power, he seldom felt the need to agonize over his words or his image. Indeed, he was every inch the happy warrior, a sharp-tongued figure who freely expressed his opinions.

Yet in the aftermath of his indictment Monday on charges of perjury and obstruction of justice, some wonder whether the very traits that propelled Finneran’s rise to power — a self-confidence bordering on the cocksure, a reflexive refusal to yield on points large or small, an eager appetite for political combat — may have worked together to hasten his fall.

”Hubris,” said Pamela Wilmot, executive director of Common Cause of Massachusetts, speculating on why Finneran denied any involvement in the redistricting process. ”There would have been no consequences to him had he told the truth: ‘Yes, I met with lawmakers and talked about this; yes, I met with the chairman of the committee.’ There would have been no repercussions. People would have said, ‘Look, there’s Finneran controlling the process again, but that would been, ‘Yawn, yawn, what’s new?’ ”

Finneran has vigorously maintained his innocence. Moreover, he has done so with the unambiguous force that characterized his eight years as House speaker, issuing a statement saying, ”My response to the charges brought against me today is NOT GUILTY,” and telling reporters: ”I’m not going to lose any sleep over it.”

If that is true, that would mean Finneran is less bothered by the indictment than are some of his admirers. Former House speaker David Bartley contended that the indictment is ”just outrageous,” and that Finneran is called arrogant simply for exerting strong leadership and for being unyielding in his beliefs.

Such support is a testament to the charisma and brainpower Finneran brought to the post of House speaker, along with an iron-fisted approach that made dissidents an endangered species. Critics say Finneran’s belief that he was smarter than most — an opinion honed and to an extent affirmed in the State House — contributed to his current legal predicament. In this view, the commanding — critics called it arrogant — demeanor that defined his leadership in the House simply boomeranged on the witness stand.

”He was just daring the attorneys to challenge him, to doubt him,” remarked Representative James J. Marzilli, a Democrat from Arlington who was often at loggerheads with Finneran during the decade-plus they served together in the House. ”You carry that outside this chamber, this institution, and people are a lot less willing to live by the rules he’s trying to force upon them.”

His will was so fierce, his talents so outsized, that Finneran grew used to getting his way on Beacon Hill. Often, his word literally was law. Now a jury will decide whether he broke the law with a few words of emphatic denial when he was asked, under oath, whether he knew the contents of a legislative redistricting plan before it was made public.

Lou DiNatale, director of the Center for Economic and Civic Opinion at the University of Massachusetts at Lowell, said it was clear from the former speaker’s testimony that he found it ”outrageous he had to testify before a federal jury over something that speakers have done over time immemorial in every state in the country . . . to protect his party members, Democrats, and his leadership. He made a mistake. He assumed this wasn’t going to be as explosive a public issue as it became.”

Whatever the outcome, the indictment has refocused the spotlight on a figure as compelling as he is contradictory. Finneran is a student of history who loves Edward Gibbon’s ”The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire” and Winston Churchill’s ”The Gathering Storm,” but he didn’t seem to see the storm gathering around him or to apprehend that his own pride and power might lead to a fall. In interviews with admirers and detractors of the former speaker, it was striking how often the twin themes of ambition and tragedy were sounded.

”Tom Finneran thought he was going to be either mayor of Boston or a United States senator,” said John McDonough, a former legislator and now executive director of Health Care for All, a consumer advocacy group. ”He clearly saw the speakership not as a terminal position but as a launching pad for something bigger. Given his ambitions, there’s a note of tragedy in it, that someone so gifted and talented was not able to capitalize on his position to achieve that bigger goal.”

Barbara Anderson, head of Citizens for Limited Taxation, considered Finneran to have ”a very thin skin stretched over a very big ego” from the day in 1991 when he ignored her outstretched hand and stalked away from her after the two did battle over Proposition 2 1/2, the tax-limiting measure that was her brainchild. Nonetheless, Anderson said, she now views Finneran as ”a tragic figure who had tremendous potential for leadership but instead he got lost in his own hubris.”

Over time, Finneran became known for what he said as much as for what he did. In the middle of the 1998 debate over how much public financing should be given to New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft to build a new stadium, Finneran at a dinner in Peabody dismissed the idea of a tax break for the project with a vulgarity.

In 1998, at a post-primary unity breakfast after Scott Harshbarger had won the Democratic gubernatorial nomination, the facade of unity crumbled in a hurry when Finneran floated the notion that Harshbarger might drift toward ”the loony left,” a blow to a nominee who hoped and needed to appeal to moderate voters.

But for all of his swagger, the depictions of Finneran as a cartoon tyrant miss the mark, insist many who served with him, including some who lined up against him on issues or on leadership style. Most describe a man who was unfailingly cordial, who invariably recalled the names of members’ spouses and children, and who would blink back tears while discussing the challenges facing the mentally retarded.

Representative Michael Festa, a Melrose Democrat who emerged as one of Finneran’s leading critics, said, ”It’s a rare member of the House that would say they didn’t like Tom Finneran.”

Even though Festa often spoke out against Finneran’s tight control of the House, the two enjoyed a friendly relationship based on a shared love of gardening, and Festa had Finneran and his wife as a guest at his house several times. ”The man is sufficiently complex for everyone to understand he’s not that one-dimensional as a person,” Festa said.

Yet the image that came through to the outside world sometimes lacked those other dimensions. Having entered the Legislature in his late 20s, Finneran perhaps inevitably leaned on the instincts and style of a State House insider. But that very style may have worked against him on the witness stand, in the view of DiNatale, who believes that the indictment is unfair.

”Finneran got popped for the wink and the nod,” DiNatale contended. ”Because the culture of the [State House] building is ‘I know and you don’t know what’s really going on,’ the wink and the nod is the dominant form of being in the know. . . . You can play these winking games with the press, you can even play them with the Legislature. You can’t play them under oath.”

Rick Klein and Jonathan Saltzman of the Globe staff contributed to this report.